“Inasmuch as marriage is the legal union of only one man and one woman as
husband and wife, no other legal union that is treated as marriage or the
substantial equivalent thereof shall be valid or recognized.’’ — Amendment
2
Saturday’s editions of The News-Press and news-press.com reported the
Florida Marriage Protection Amendment is on the rocks.
This revelation
comes four days before votes are tallied.
“I do’’ voters for Amendment 2
total 55 percent support — short of the 60 percent required — according to a
Mason-Dixon poll of 625 likely voters.
Thirty-five percent oppose the gay
marriage ban. Ten percent don’t know.
Undecideds will determine pass or
fail.
Polls, of course, will be polls.
A week earlier, a St.
Petersburg Times/Bay News 9/Miami Herald poll reported 59 percent of 800 likely
voters want to amend the Florida Constitution.
Sixty-nine percent of
black voters support the ban, which translates to passage if Democratic
presidential candidate Barack Obama drives huge black turnout, according to the
St. Petersburg Times.
So, who do we believe?
We’ll find out
Tuesday.
But for now, let’s see what Lee County says. I canvassed 15
early voters Wednesday at the Supervisor of Elections Office on the third floor
of the Constitutional Complex in Fort Myers.
Seven voted no. Five voted
yes. Three wouldn’t say.
Here is a sampling of six:
“I don’t agree
with same-sex marriage,” says Winnette Austin of Fort Myers, 46. “I’m old
school. I don’t feel what they are doing is right.’’
Cassandra Love, 50,
of Fort Myers says 2 is No. 1 for her.
“I just want marriage to be a man and a woman,’’ she says. “That’s the only
thing I’ve ever known. It was how I was brought up.’’
Colby Teel, 34, of
Fort Myers says he sticks with the Bible.
“I’m a Christian. I don’t have
anything against gays,’’ he says. “But a true marriage is between a man and a
woman.’’
But three, young first-time voters offset the “yes’’
votes.
“I was raised to be accepting of everything,’’ says Trisha Tucker,
18, of North Fort Myers. “Just because it’s not my choice doesn’t mean it’s
wrong.’’
Julie Ruhl, 18, of Sanibel, says if you love someone, gay or
straight, that couple should not be denied a union.
Brian Dodd, 20, of
Fort Myers says younger folks are raised to be more open-minded.
“I’m
going to college — and equal rights are equal rights,’’ says Dodd, a Florida
Gulf Coast University sophomore. “I voted against (the gay marriage
ban).’’
If nothing else, the proposed amendment is redundant. Two state
laws already prohibit same-sex marriage.
Howard Simon, executive director
of the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, says be leery of the intent of
2.
“If they really just wanted to focus on marriage as a union between
one man and one woman, as they repeatedly claim, they would have put that
language in Amendment 2,’’ he says. “Instead they have crafted a ban on anything
that is treated as marriage or the substantial equivalent thereof.
“This
signals that, if they successfully con Florida voters on Amendment 2,
health-care benefits are the next target.’’
Simon says passage will
jeopardize health-insurance coverage and limit public and private flexibility in
extending benefits to domestic partners — gay or straight.
Simon also
says 60 state health-care professionals Friday urged Floridians to vote
“no.’’
Dr. Charles Sowder of Bonita Springs says passing Amendment 2
would deny protections of domestic partnerships.
“As an emergency room
doctor, I’ve seen committed couples irreparably harmed by being denied hospital
visitation and other fundamental human rights and benefits that married couples
take for granted,’’ says Sowder, one of the 60 pros.
Orlando attorney
John Stemberger is state chairman of Florida4Marriage.org, which sponsored
Amendment 2.
Stemberger says opponents of the amendment try to confuse
the issue by talking about health care, domestic partnerships and
benefits.
“They absolutely refuse to discuss the driving force behind why
27 states amended their state constitutions by overwhelming majorities,’’
Stemberger wrote Tuesday on Yes2Marriage.org. “(It is) to protect the definition
of marriage as the union of one man and one woman.’’
I voted no. Two
marriage laws are plenty. A third is anti-gay.
Depending on Pop-Up Blocker: Use Browser Back Button or Close Window to Return to Pride Tampa Bay's Website